Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Trust in the Judiciary: The Effect of Political Polarization

Tue, September 28, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

During the first two decades of the 21st century Israel’s Judiciary, and specifically the Supreme Court, have been under constant attack. These attacks have included, among others, hostile statements made by senior elected officials and negative coverage in several media outlets. During these same decades, public trust in the judiciary has been continuously declining, with many Israelis perceiving the court as being politically biased and promoting a political agenda through its decision making.
We will ask: A) Is the decline of trust in the judiciary stemming from controversial rulings of a court favoring one side of the political spectrum, or is the decline related to the ideological polarization of the political system and to the intentional portraying of the court as a political player promoting its own ideological agenda? B) How are both, the nominations to the judiciary as well as judicial decisions in politically charged cases influenced by these frequent attacks?
To answer these questions, two research approaches will be used: First, a historic analysis of the Supreme Court's rulings on politically charged issues that led to vicious attacks on Israel's judiciary. Second, a quantitative analysis based on surveys of the “Israeli Democracy Index”, broad yearly public opinion polls based on a representative sample of the adult population in Israel.
Our findings show that while the Supreme Court is much more careful than in the past in intervening in the decisions of elected office holders, public trust in the institution has taken a sharp dive. The politicization of the judicial system undermines the public’s trust in the judiciary and presents a danger to judicial independence.

Authors