Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Does Gender Shape Oversight?: The Case of the Colombian Congress

Sat, October 2, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Do men and women conduct oversight at equal rates? Men and women elected to office are tasked with two priorities, lawmaking and oversight. While often overlooked in research, oversight is an important democratic principal that ensures accountable governance, and given the unique position of women in government, men and women are likely to prioritize oversight and lawmaking differently. Introducing a theory of strategic resource allocation that combines research on women’s risk preferences, electoral fortunes, and legislative activity, I theorize that women are more oversight-driven than men because they allocate their limited time and resources differently between their roles as legislators and overseers. I expect that women will be more oversight driven as a result of their more cautious natures, and given their perceived expertise, they will be even more oversight-driven in traditionally feminine issue areas. I hypothesize that women are more oversight-driven and that they are more likely to conduct oversight in women’s issue areas. I expect that differences in oversight behavior may be one mechanism for women’s presence in government reducing perceptions of corruption.

To test these hypotheses, I use oversight committee data from the Colombian Congress (2014-2018) on the use of subpoena meetings. I focus on the case of Colombia as the opposition have successfully strengthened the role of oversight in the governing process and committees clearly delineate oversight and legislation. I first analyze legislator-session level data to explore if women have a higher proclivity to exercise a legislator’s constitutional right to subpoena members of the executive. I then analyze meeting level to predict the gender of the meeting overseer. While I do not find legislator-specific effects, I do find that women are more likely to conduct oversight in high visibility committees and when the issue is stereotypically feminine. This suggests that women may be acting strategically, just not in a way that we would normally consider. Women may employ oversight as a way to work around the traditional channels of public recognition in their role as legislators that are most often controlled by men.

Author