Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Saving Lives, Reopening the Economy: State Responses to the COVID-19 Pandemic

Wed, September 29, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

The paper examines public policymaking during the COVID-19 pandemic. The paper asks why some states pursued a relaxation of these interventions despite not meeting CDC benchmarks for “reopening” while others did not. We argue that state-level responses were constrained by the federal system of governance and trace this governing arrangement over social policy to neoliberal policy reforms of the late twentieth century. While states possessed the police powers necessary to compel compliance, only the federal government possessed the fiscal capacity necessary to mitigate the economic costs associated with shelter-in-place orders and the closure of non-essential businesses. As national leaders (including the president) focused increasingly on the idea of “reopening” the economy rather than providing direct financial supports, Congress refrained from considering additional major legislation, and the window for reconceptualization of the welfare state was swiftly closed. Our explanation of how and why some states more readily complied with calls to reopen the economy as opposed to others, highlights the significance of late twentieth-century neoliberal policy legacies that fostered distinctive state-level policy regimes. In the wake of the transformation of national welfare to state-led workfare, states differentially assembled policy regimes focused primarily on regulation or redistribution that disparately addressed, constructed, and shaped unequal safety net protections across racial, gender, and employment categories. The paper identifies and assembles the ideational and institutional mechanisms of states’ welfare policy regimes to explain their differing responses to the question of when and how to reopen their economies during the pandemic, all of which has served to instantiate disproportionate economic harms on racial minorities across states. By centralizing the significance of state-level policy regimes alongside federal governance arrangements the paper seeks to contribute to public policy literature that connects the rise and development of the neoliberal policy state to the production and embedment of social marginality, and demonstrates its fortitude and enduring policy significance despite the massive scale of the COVID disruption.

Authors