Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In 2018, Congress passed the FIRST STEP Act reforming the federal criminal justice system. The Act was hailed by lawmakers as a turning point that marked a bipartisan rejection of the politics that long fueled mass incarceration. The law aimed to shrink the federal prison population, lower recidivism rates, promote reentry, and significantly reduce racial disparities in federal criminal justice outcomes. With such unobjectionable goals, the bill sailed through the House and Senate by wide margins before securing President Trump’s signature. But despite the FIRST STEP Act’s ostensibly laudable and reform-oriented aims, close analysis of its passage reveals that many of its key provisions reflect and reinforce punitive ideologies that have long fostered and sustained racial inequalities in American criminal justice.
This paper is part of a larger book project exploring the development of the rehabilitative ideal in American crime politics. From its origins, rehabilitative ideology has relied on distinguishing between inmates in ways that have justified compassionate treatment for inmates deemed “curable” and harsh punitive treatment for those deemed “incurable.” The book’s historical perspective demonstrates that rehabilitative ideology has long reserved the label of “incurability” for poor minority entrants into the justice system. Lawmakers reinvigorated the ideology of rehabilitation when constructing central elements of the FIRST STEP Act, and the results will likely exacerbate rather than reduce racial inequalities in federal prisons. Particularly, lawmakers reinvigorated the ideology of rehabilitation when fighting for the inclusion of risk assessment mechanisms intended to guide correctional officials’ decisions over how to manage inmates and whether or not to offer them therapeutic and rehabilitative interventions. Risk assessments are designed to evaluate each offender’s unique risk of recidivism and personal potential for reform, and lawmakers defended them as essential tools for furthering the state’s rehabilitative goals. But while risk assessments have long been presented as objective appraisals of the individual, in reality they reflect racialized and middle-class assumptions about what causes crime and how criminal actors can best be reformed. By disguising a subjective judgment laden with racial and class assumptions as a scientific calculation of an individual’s personal risks and needs, risk assessments readily legitimize harsh treatment for poor minority citizens. In the FIRST STEP Act, risk assessments were presented as vital to promoting a renewed federal emphasis on rehabilitating inmates by empowering correctional officials to identify which offenders were reformable while determining which ones had risk levels rendering them so irredeemable that incarceration was necessary. This, according to lawmakers, would enhance the federal government’s rehabilitative program and improve recidivism reduction rates by weeding out unreformable offenders at their point of entry into the system and prevent corrections officials from wasting valuable resources on individuals whose risk rendered them irreversibly criminal. The law thus presented risk assessments as a central component of rehabilitative programming. Given the racial assumptions embedded into risk assessments and rehabilitative ideology, these elements of the FIRST STEP Act will likely increase rather than reduce racial inequality by ensuring that the federal prison population subjected to incarceration without any opportunities for rehabilitation will disproportionately consist of minority inmates.
From its inception in the late nineteenth century through today, rehabilitative ideology has repeatedly produced punitive and racialized outcomes in American criminal justice, and this case study serves as the book project’s final perspective on the rehabilitative ideal’s damaging impact on U.S. crime policy. Despite the FIRST STEP Act’s praiseworthy stated purposes, we must understand how rehabilitative logic shaped the law’s undesirable and potentially damaging elements if we are to fully challenge the politics driving mass incarceration today.