Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

John Stuart Mill and the Performance of Democracy

Sat, October 2, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

This paper reads J.S. Mill’s On Liberty and Considerations on Representative Government in light of his evocation of Greek classical figures including Socrates and Pericles, as well as his broader idealized celebration of classical Athenian democracy. It finds that his defense of liberty and his more problematic commitment to unequal weighted voting both reflect a basic concern with the aesthetic education of citizens through the example of elite public service and debate. This reading charts a middle course between interpretations of Mill that tend to downplay the importance of his elitist unequal voting scheme, and those who defend it on epistemic grounds. Mill’s evocation of an idealized Athenian public sphere reveals that fostering the expression of a multiplicity of perspectives, rather than maintenance of elite control, is his goal through unequal voting procedures. The spectacle of a diversity of viewpoints engaged in peaceful disagreement is intended to be educative for all citizens who witness it. Mill’s idealized evocation of Greek individuals further speaks to a substantive conception of the good life which can be achieved by way of this educative public spectacle. Mill thus anticipates and counters many of the common criticisms of contemporary liberalism as a morally vacuous ideology, on the one hand, or a tool of elite power, on the other. Mill’s concern with aesthetic education through the example of political debate provides a productive response in particular to concerns about democratic politics in our age of mass communication and entertainment. Rather than fruitlessly bemoaning the presence of spectacle, and the weaponization of spectacle by unsavory characters, Mill’s liberalism invites us to consider how to turn the power of spectacle towards the productive and necessary work of education through example.

Author