Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Weight of Territorial Issues in Catalonia, Scotland and Norther Ireland

Sun, October 3, 12:00 to 1:30pm PDT (12:00 to 1:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Debates about territorial sovereignty complicate the politics within the regions of dispute. Regional political candidates often take positions on the contentious issue of autonomy or independence. Yet, empirical evidence is mixed as to whether clear positions on that issue benefit or disadvantage such candidates. Do individuals weight territorial issues more than other policy issues? We hypothesize that the position the candidate takes on the territorial question supersedes other issue disagreements for citizens who have clear preferences on this issue (for example, in favour or against independence). We present new evidence using detailed survey evidence from three regions in European democracies where territorial debates are salient and contentious - Catalonia and Scotland, where some seek independence – along with Northern Ireland, where some seek the unification with Ireland. Using a conjoint experiment embedded in a survey which was fielded simultaneously across the three regions, we find that, on average, territorial positions are not the most electorally beneficial nor costly—other issues such as social spending and immigration can matter as much electorally. However, for voters who have strong territorial preferences, this issue weighs more than the others in that they are less willing to trade it off. Our results have implications for political competition in multidimensional spaces where territorial issues are present.

Authors