Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In a 1970 issue of the New York Review of Books, John William Ward resurrected a great work of anarchist political theory that remains understudied today: Alexander Berkman’s 1912 Prison Memoirs of an Anarchist. With the revolutionary politics of his own period as primer, Ward wrote that the long-buried book “allows us to experience violence from the inside, to identify with a man who idealistically accepts terrorism as a political instrument.” During the Homestead strike of 1892, the prominent anarchist Berkman had attempted to assassinate the manager of the Carnegie steel works in Homestead, Pennsylvania. He and his comrade Emma Goldman hoped that the attentat would provoke workers to revolution – but he could not kill Frick, and the workers would not rise up. Whereas Goldman’s own autobiography focused on a lifetime of radical action in America and abroad, Berkman’s book was a meditation on that act and what it revealed of his life and the political potential of Americans. Thus Ward saw in the book a question still contentious in 1970: “is violence, rather than some mad aberration, an intrinsic and understandable part of America?”
Reading the book in 2021, I argue that Berkman’s Prison Memoirs of an Anarchist raises the question not only of violence but of captivity as an essential element of America. Although incarceration played an important role for in the analyses of earlier dissidents like Henry David Thoreau, Peter Kropotkin, and Mikhail Bakunin, Berkman’s book focuses on what the prison means for radicalism and politics in the United States. Imprisonment provokes not only Berkman’s reflections on violence – as Ward argues and as I elaborate – but new understandings of solidarity, queer intimacy, and the change required of actors to achieve radical political outcomes. Prison is not only the government’s response to deviance but emblematic of a broader American captivity to certain forms of consciousness and ideology: what Berkman described by letter to Goldman as “the popular delusion of self-government and independence.”
This study situates Berkman’s book alongside other anarchist writings at the time (including his sub rosa writings with Henry Bauer and Carl Nold) and within that transitional 1970 moment in which Ward reviewed it. The following year, Ward would become president of Amherst College while the imprisoned George Jackson – one of the “Soledad Brothers” alleged to have killed a guard – would be gunned down in a San Quentin prison yard for an alleged escape attempt. Two years later in his own autobiography, Huey Newton drew on the same nihilist authors that inspired Berkman as he challenged his incarceration and American injustice. As the dreams of 1960s radical politics waned and the roots of mass incarceration thickened, this was a pivotal period in radical thinking on captivity. Thus the greater goal of this essay is not simply to recover an important work of anarchist theory, but to excavate key connections in how American radicals of both the late nineteenth and mid-twentieth centuries theorized captivity in their analyses and activism.