Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Many North American scholars of prison abolition depict Michel Foucault as a prison abolitionist (Andrew Dilts & Perry Zurn, Chloë Taylor). There is no doubt that Foucault resisted prisons through both his scholarship and his activism with the Prisons Information Group (GIP), and many US-based abolitionists have drawn fruitfully on his work (Liat Ben-Moshe, Dean Spade). Yet neither Foucault nor the GIP used the language of abolition to describe their efforts, which Foucault later theorized instead as problematization. This terminology, I argue, reveals important differences between Foucault’s prison politics and the abolitionism most visible in the US today, rooted in Black Marxist struggle and represented by scholar-activists Angela Davis and Ruth Gilmore. The differences, which have gone largely unexplored in abolitionist writings, do not just concern the history of the prison and its relationship to racism (Davis, Joy James), but also visions of political struggle and democracy. While the two approaches converge on many points—both critique reformism, seek to disrupt common sense, and endorse pragmatic political collaboration—Davis and Gilmore connect prison abolition to the creation of a democratic state that ensures equal membership and provides public goods to all. Foucauldian problematization, in contrast, neither endorses such a vision of “abolition democracy” (Davis, DuBois) nor can it sustain the collective organizing required to seize state resources and capacities in this way. Problematization, I suggest, is best understood as a component of abolitionist struggle, not as synonymous with it.