Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Story vs. the Storyteller: Rhetoric, Representation, and the JCPOA

Tue, September 28, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

How does the personality of an individual leader relate to the personality of the state? What happens when leaders pursue policies that put them at odds with widely accepted national narratives? In this paper, I draw upon political theories of representation to shed new light on how domestic-level narrative contestation affects U.S. foreign policy. The deep ambiguities of representation (Brito Vieira and Runciman 2008) are often elided in IR scholarship. State narratives appear more unitary projected outward than inward. At the domestic level, plurality is an assumed problem (Runciman 1997). But IR tends to attribute the actions of leaders to states automatically (Fleming 2017). There are pragmatic reasons for doing so, namely the structure of the current international system, but the problem, as I will show in this paper, is that the plurality of narrators at the domestic level can meaningfully affect foreign policy outcomes. This becomes evident in the move from theory to practice. If representatives automatically speak for the state, why do political leaders devote so much time and energy to ‘selling’ their desired policies? And if responsibility attribution is not automatic, then what makes representative speaking-for legitimate? My paper focuses on the Iran Nuclear Deal, which pitted an authorized narrator—the Obama administration—against the widely accepted narrative that cast Iran and the United States as implacable foes. I show how Congress, the media, and public opinion thwarted responsibility attribution by upholding the narrative status quo, leaving the JCPOA vulnerable to political transition. The ease with which the Trump administration pulled out of the Iran Deal highlighted structural problems that have precipitated a representation crisis in U.S. foreign policy. This raises an important question: when future presidents try to change relations through diplomacy, will they be taken as speaking for the state, or simply for themselves?

Author