Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

What a Riot! Activism, Moral Holidays, and the Carnival of Modern U.S. Democracy

Tue, September 28, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

We live in a world inundated with causes. Just as the body can become fatigued by exertion, so too can the mind, emotions, and soul. Pathways to a meaningful life are not clear or easy, and many experience burn-out and “activism fatigue” in their efforts to better the world, especially in democratic societies which solicit engagement as a precondition of governance. Moral holidays are an idea advanced by pragmatist philosopher William James which warrants attention as a possible justification for how to proceed in times of personal fatigue. When a person feels overwhelmed in their activism, they may turn to a moral holiday, taking a step back from the anxieties of the world and allowing others to engage directly in the active work of advocacy and societal improvement until they rest and recalibrate. In this essay, I will first discuss the idea of a moral holiday in greater detail, both in James’s view as well as in conversation with philosophy at large. Next, I show that while James’s idea of a moral holiday is an enticing option to avail when addressing contemporary pressures from democratic activism, there are some potential drawbacks and open questions which could ultimately undermine the very societies and governments for which so many care so deeply. The third section of this paper discusses how Bahktin’s notion of carnival interpolates with democratic theory and the contemporary understanding of riots and political advocacy more broadly. Ultimately, I argue that while moral holidays seem as if they could play a valuable function in society if utilized well, they in practice harm democratic commitments and make activism even harder, largely as a result of fracturing trust, further entrenching white supremacy, and revealing chasms of division in society.

Author