Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
I argue that republicanism can serve as a normative framework for pluralistic political communities, but only through a radical reimagining, from the perspective of the republican tradition, of what it means to exercise political agency.
One is a citizen, in the republican tradition, because she contributes to the polity. This conception of citizenship is widely seen as hierarchical and exclusionary. On the standard republican view, one must already be free in order to contribute as a citizen: the republican citizen must be rich enough to both maintain herself and support the polity, educated to argue eloquently and persuasively, and instilled with sufficient virtue to sacrifice her personal interests for the greater good. In practice, the realization of these characteristics requires the exploitation of others whose labor enables the citizen to participate in political life.
Yet it is not necessary to understand contribution to the polity in this inevitably exclusionary way. Drawing on the political thought of Frederick Douglass, I argue that a pluralistic conception of republican citizenship characterizes contribution in terms of shaping the normative foundation of the polity. We make ourselves citizens, on this account, by acting in concert with others to contest what the polity values. Contesting the normative foundation of the polity does not require that one is already free. Rather, the free citizen is forged through struggle against tyranny and oppression. It is in this sense that Douglass’s republicanism is abolitionist: an inclusive polity is realized through resistance against oppressive institutions and ideologies.
Douglass himself develops a version of this view in his antebellum planation politics: his account of how enslaved Black Americans constitute themselves as citizens through coordinated, quotidian resistance against the slave system and white supremacy. But Douglass’s postbellum politics illustrate the limits of this account, as when he supports imperialist intervention by the US in the Dominican Republic (i.e. the annexation of Santo Domingo) for the sake of forging a more robust inter-American political community.
The trajectory of Douglass’s political thought demonstrates a fundamental tension in the republican conception of citizenship. On the one hand, republicanism emphasizes the ways in which each of us possesses political agency to forge and contribute to political communities. On the other hand, because oppressive ideology renders the contributions of subordinated people illegible to the wider polity, republicanism tends to privilege the contributions of the already powerful. Efforts to reforge radically inclusive political communities by emphasizing the value of contribution to the polity always pose the danger of reinforcing hierarchies that subordinate the already marginalized, to the extent that they adopt traditional, exclusionary conceptions of political agency. The conceptual challenge for a pluralistic republicanism is to articulate a conception of what it is to contribute to a political community that renders the contributions of marginalized persons and groups legible to the wider polity. I argue that Douglass’s own antebellum efforts to render the contributions of free and enslaved Black people in the US legible show us what it looks like to address this challenge. A faithful reconstruction of Douglass’s abolitionist republicanism takes its cue from his antebellum political project, while remaining ever-vigilant to the exclusionary pitfalls exemplified in his postbellum thought.