Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Heller’s Concept of ‘Authoritarian Liberalism’ Revisited

Fri, October 1, 12:00 to 1:30pm PDT (12:00 to 1:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

My paper argues for a new understanding of Hermann Heller’s constitutional thought, focusing on his response to the Preußenschlag of 1932 as a pivotal moment in the development of his ideas. I do this by exploring an understudied 1933 essay, titled “Autoritärer Liberalismus?”, “Authoritarian Liberalism”. My paper argues that this contribution – and Heller’s many in-depth commentaries on Weimar Germany’s turn to dictatorship – cannot be fully understood without a thorough investigation of the German center left’s confused response to the various constitutional crises that shaped the history of the Weimar Republic. Be it the Kapp-Putsch of 1920, the Beer Hall Putsch of 1923, or the socio-economic devastations that followed the so-called ‘Great Crash’ of 1929 – many left liberal and socialist intellectuals again and again perceived their highly critical view of parliamentary democracy confirmed by these events. Only a charismatic, forceful leader, they were certain, could lead the Republic out of its misery and unite a fragmented German nation.

Rather than reading such arguments as confirmation for the Weimar state’s seemingly inevitable failure, the paper takes seriously and seeks to understand these contemporaries’ perception of living through a permanent state of emergency. Adherent to a dialectical view of history, a large fraction of the bourgeois left remained convinced of the historical inevitability of a nationalist counter-revolution long after 1918/19 and they continued to explore a presidential ‘dictatorship’, a rule by decree, as a means to preempt this threat. The paper for the first time reads Heller’s constitutional commentary of 1932/33 against the backdrop of this philosophically burdened inner-party debate. On the one hand, Heller’s 1933 essay dismantled any calling for a ‘total’, abstract state as deceptive; on the other, the essay established how the author’s many enthusiastic pleas for parliamentarism, the separation of powers, and economic equality were not just directed against Carl Schmitt or the Papen circle but always also formed a ‘counteroffer’ to the left: Perhaps, standing in for the Republic unanimously and by all possible means would have been the true ‘counter-revolution’ for the German nation – one directed not against but towards democracy.

Author