Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In Democratic Vistas (1871), Walt Whitman famously said, “in the future of These States must . . . arise Poets immenser far, and make great poems of Death. The poems of Life are great, but there must be the poems of the purports of life, not only in itself, but beyond itself.” This pronouncement comes toward the end of a long appeal for the rise for a new class of authors who can observe the wild variety of everyday democratic life, detect its beauty and sublimity, represent that beauty and sublimity in artistically ingenious ways, and win from their audience a commitment to democracy as a way of life, as a manner of being in the world.
Why, according to Whitman, did America need great poems of death? First, great poems of death could relieve mortal anxiety in their audience, and in so doing, open that audience up to a more intense and loving engagement with life. Democratic Vistas characterizes “shuddering at death” as beneath the dignity of the democratic individual. If democratic poets could persuade their audience to see death as constitutive of the human condition—to accept it as an indispensable part of nature rather than as a curse stemming from original sin—then that audience would be one step closer to Whitman’s ethical ideal of finding it “enough merely to live.” In their ordinary “relations to sky, air, water, trees, &c., and to the countless common shows, and in the fact of Life itself,” the democratic individual would “discover and achieve happiness,” without viewing mortality as cause for anguish.
Second, great poems of death could be America’s claim to national artistic immortality. Throughout Democratic Vistas, Whitman worries—like Emerson in “The American Scholar” (1837)—that the United States has not produced any original literature of lasting value. Without such literature, the nation condemns itself to historical obscurity. One of Whitman’s central preoccupations in Vistas is the world historical significance of the American project, and the nation’s ability to impress posterity by distilling its distinctive genius into “archetypal poems”:
It must still be reiterated . . . the deep lesson of history and time, that all else in the contributions of a nation or age, through its politics, materials, heroic personalities, military eclat, &c., remains crude, and defers . . . until vitalized by national, original archetypes in literature. They only put the nation in form, finally tell anything—prove, complete anything—perpetuate anything.
“Immortal Judah lives, and Greece immortal lives,” Whitman insisted, “in a couple of poems.”
Democratic Vistas thus takes two conflicting positions on death. The first is a non-sovereign, mortalist position viewing death as indispensable to human identity, even human dignity—in Stephen K. White’s words, a “bearing witness truthfully to my condition of subjection to mortality.” The second is a sovereign, immortalist position that craves everlasting fame—a craving the author claims to feel on behalf of his nation, but which we cannot help but suspect he also feels on his own behalf. Democratic Vistas counsels, on the one hand, humble acceptance of human finitude, and on the other, heroic reaching for immortality. This paper examines this conflict within Democratic Vistas, and argues that it provides a window on to more obviously political conflicts in Whitman’s post-war thought: between equality and greatness, between freedom and perfectionism, and between presentist and futurist ethical orientations, and between black and American identities. Contrary to prevailing readings of Democratic Vistas that portray it as a great democratic work, I argue that its sovereign, immortalist ethics—which eclipse its non-sovereign, mortalist ethics—invest the text with a heroic quality and a spirit of overcoming hostile to the democratic ordinary. Democratic Vistas is far less democratic than we usually acknowledge.