Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Racism and Sexism Benefit Conservative (Not White or Male) Politicians

Tue, September 28, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Past studies revealed that whereas racism undermined support for Barack Obama, sexism undermined support for Hillary Clinton. The conventional theories from this line of work is that racism and sexism among voters can hurt politicians that are racial minority and/or female because they are minority or female. The current project suggests otherwise. Using large samples that are nationally diverse or nationally representative (total N=44,836), this talk presents evidence that citizens’ prejudice does not usually benefit or undermine politicians who are from a particular demographic group, as many past studies assumed; instead, citizens’ prejudice is associated with support for conservative politicians and opposition to liberal politicians, regardless of politicians’ demographic background.
Studies 1a and 1b show that, racism and sexism negatively predict evaluation of real liberal politicians, even though some of them are White or male (i.e., Obama, Sanders, Clinton). In contrast, racism and sexism in most cases positively predict evaluation of real conservative politicians, even though some of them are Black or women (i.e., Trump, Carson, Fiorina). This overall pattern is experimentally confirmed in Study 2 using a 2 x 2 x 2 x 2 design, in which participants responded to measures of racism and sexism first and then evaluate a hypothetical candidate whose race (Black vs White), gender (male vs female), ideology (liberal vs conservative), and party affiliation (Republican vs Democrat) are manipulated.
Study 3 shows that, historically, the predictive effect of prejudice on evaluation of real politicians in general is moderated by (perceived) politicians’ ideology. Participants who score high on prejudice evaluate politicians they perceive to be conservative favorably but politicians that they perceive to be liberal unfavorably, even though most of them are White male. Studies 4 and 5 show that the results generalize to other racism measures that are non-specific to anti-Black racism (Study 4) and a racism measure in the implicit domain (Study 5). Study 6 extends the results for prejudice to the religious domain (i.e., prejudice toward Muslims).
Hence, current studies highlight the often-overlooked role of politicians’ ideology in the expression of racism and sexism. These results espouse an ideological, not demographical, explanation for the effect of prejudice on the evaluation of politicians. Together, these studies 1. prompt researchers to re-interpret the implications of past findings about the association between racism, sexism and evaluation of politicians, 2. clarify theories that explain how citizens’ prejudice is translated into their political preferences, and 3. help us understand exactly what types of societal consequences citizens’ prejudice might lead to.

Author