Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Researchers have envisioned entertainment media, particularly fictional television programming, as a pathway for political persuasion. Yet studies of television viewing patterns have identified that conservatives and liberals watch different types of television entertainment content. Despite these findings, there remains an assumption that most viewers choose their entertainment media absent of political considerations. Whereas news or satire/late-night comedy programming often depicts “explicitly” political objects, the bulk of fictional programming instead depicts “implicitly” political objects. I contend that viewers may indeed evaluate this programming as being relevant to politics and that these evaluations predict selective exposure behaviors.
I define the evaluation of the political relevance of media as “a person’s assessment of how relevant to the political realm a particular media text is” (Author, under review, p. 4). Author (under review) developed and validated the Politically Relevant Media (PRM) scale to measure these evaluations. Author further contrasted the PRM scale with simply asking participants to evaluate media texts in terms of how “political” they were, noting that the ways that people use the terms “political” and “politics” cast doubt on the appropriateness of such a measure when measuring evaluations of “implicitly” political media.
The Current Study
The current study investigates whether evaluating “implicitly” political fictional entertainment media content as politically relevant will be positively related to selective exposure. I use a repeated-measures design in which participants evaluate four mock television shows “in development.” I hypothesizes that PRM evaluations would be positively predictive of selective exposure behaviors, and that these evaluations would mediate the relationship between political identity strength (Author, under review; Settle, 2018) and selective exposure. I also compare the predictive and mediating power of PRM evaluations to how participants evaluate media as “political.”
Method
I recruited 666 U.S. adults via Qualtrics, with quotas for partisanship set to evenly split the sample between Democrats, Republicans, and Independents/Others. Additional quotas were set to ensure the sample was reflective of the U.S. population in terms of gender, age, and income.
The study employed a 2 (show position: Republican/conservative vs. Democratic/liberal) x 2 (genre: sitcom vs. drama) x 4 (issue: the cost of healthcare, marijuana as a public safety issue, the cost of environmental protection, or religious freedom and LGBTQ discrimination) design. None of the issues were described in terms related to politicians, parties, electoral processes (Author, under review).
Participants answered questions regarding political interest, political identity strength, and demographics. Next, each show description was randomly presented, followed by the PRM scale and single “political” item. Participants then ranked the shows based on which they would most like to watch, allowing me to compute a selective exposure score.
Results
I tested my hypotheses using mediation analyses by running linear mixed models on 5,000 bootstrapped samples of the dataset. PRM has a positive, statistically significant effect on selective exposure. In contrast, the single “political” item did not predict selective exposure. PRM is also a statistically significant mediator in the relationship between political identity strength and selective exposure, but the “political” item is not. As a robustness check, I also conducted a parallel mediation analysis, with both PRM and “political” in the same model. There is a statistically significant indirect effect of political identity strength on selective exposure through PRM, but not through the “political” item.
Discussion
The current study found that individuals engage in greater levels of selective exposure to “implicitly” political fictional entertainment media they evaluated as more politically relevant than for programs they evaluated as less politically relevant. These PRM evaluations mediated the relationship between political identity strength and selective exposure.
The finding of selective exposure to “implicitly” political fictional entertainment television programs has tremendous implications for viewers’ media selection habits, the cultivation of different media ecosystems for those who hold disparate political attitudes, and the possibilities for narrative persuasion. This could lead to the reinforcing of political identities and the further selection of “implicitly” political media that confirms one’s political beliefs. This is all the more reason why political communication scholars should focus increased attention on how people evaluate “implicitly” political entertainment media as politically relevant and what the effects could be on media selection and persuasion.