Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Confucianism has long been seen as being incompatible with liberal neutrality. Confucianism is a perfectionist theory originated in ancient China. In Confucian ethics, human beings are naturally born with some moral sensibilities that incline them toward becoming virtuous. By cultivating these sensibilities, human beings can, like the growth of plants from nascent sprout to full flower, achieve the objectively valuable ideals of sagehood (聖人). Liberal neutrality is a political principle that a legitimate state must remain neutral between competing, irreconcilable conceptions of the good life. The reasons that justify state actions should not be perfectionist considerations or metaphysical beliefs that are accepted as valid reasons by only a sect of citizens who uphold certain conception of the good. Only when state actions can be justified by public reasons that are acceptable to all reasonable citizens, these actions are legitimate. According to this principle, promoting an officially recognized state religion and prohibiting other religions are plainly impermissible. Furthermore, when citizens advocate a political standpoint about how state power should be exercised, they should also justify it by public reasons that other citizens see as valid. This principle is advocated by early liberals like John Locke, and is recently endorsed by contemporary liberals, such as John Rawls, Charles Larmore, Robert Audi, Gerald Gaus, Martha Nussbaum, and even politicians like Barack Obama.
Due to the perfectionist view, Contemporary Confucians usually reject the principle of liberal neutrality. Confucianism has two goals: an ethical goal of “self-development” (xiu shen 修身) and a political goal of “well-ordered state” (zhi guo治國) and “the pacification of the world” (ping tianxia 平天下). The latter is interpreted in terms of the former. An ideal political order is an order that aims for the ethical perfection of all people. Each person is able to live the objectively good way of life stipulated in Confucian ethics. While sagehood is a shared conception of flourishing that people from different places and widely diverse backgrounds should all pursue, it is legitimate for a state to use state power to assist people to develop their moral potential. In short, Confucian political theory is a perfectionist theory, which argues that a state should not be neutral and should promote Confucian perfectionist values. Contemporary Confucians, such as Daniel Bell, Qing Jiang, Tan Sor-hoon, Stephen Angle, Joseph Chan, and Kim Sungmoon, all endorse this philosophical position. Their views only differ in how these values should be promoted, radically or moderately.
By contrast with the works above, this paper argues that Confucianism should accept, rather than reject, liberal neutrality. I first argue that, in light of Loubna El Amine’s recent interpretation, a legitimate goal of traditional Confucianism is to maintain a political order of harmony, instead of cultivating every society member to be virtuous. I then argue that, even in East Asia, deep pluralism in metaphysical and ethical beliefs exist in modern democratic societies. Although there is a thin consensus on Confucian values, this consensus is not robust enough to be an uncontroversial ground for making laws and policies. I finally argue that non-coercive promotion of Confucian values by the government, such as state subsidies, would still result in sectarianism because the promotion implicitly entails an official message that Confucianism is a better comprehensive doctrine than others, and non-Confucians would suffer from expressive subordination. This would stimulate political opposition and eventually harmony would be lost. Therefore, to achieve harmony in a modern pluralistic society, a Confucian government is legitimate to refrain from promoting Confucian values and stay neutral in making laws and policies. Even though it believes that the Confucian view of human flourishing is objectively true and valuable, it should restrict itself from officially affirming this view as correct and encouraging all citizens to endorse this view. My argument can be summarized as the following:
(1) A legitimate goal of Confucianism is to maintain order, rather than cultivating virtuous citizens.
(2) The modern democratic society is characterized by deep pluralism in metaphysical and ethical beliefs. No Confucian values can be used as grounds of making laws and policies that would be widely acceptable to citizens.
(3) In a pluralistic society, using laws and policies to promote Confucianism will result in sectarianism, that threatens the political order in a way that Confucians should reject
(4) Given (1), (2) and (3), a legitimate Confucian state should endorse liberal neutrality.