Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Identifying Effective Civil Conflict Peace Agreements

Fri, October 1, 8:00 to 8:30am PDT (8:00 to 8:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

What types of peace agreements best prevent renewed violence after civil conflict? Scholars have identified a number of agreement provisions that may keep the peace, such as United Nations peacekeeping operations, post-war power sharing between the government and opposition, third party monitoring of the signatories' compliance, transitional justice reforms, and military integration of former rebels. Despite this, scholars have not systematically evaluated which reforms are most effective. Rather, researchers have relied on a priori dimension reduction - selecting and testing one or a few provisions from the wider set of possibilities or creating an agreement level construct. While this approach has improved our understanding of post-war settlements, it tells us little about what reforms produce the most durable peace. I answer this question by undertaking the first analysis of the universe of provisions using the Peace Accords Matrix implementation data. I use a statistical approach designed to counteract the high ratio of features to observations in this data. Out of forty-eight different provision types, just seven are robustly associated with war recurrence. Only four of these; amnesties, verification, dispute resolution bodies, and prisoner release, reduce the chances war recurs. Other widely cited approaches, such as power sharing, political institutional reforms, peacekeeping, and truth and justice measures are, at best, ineffective.

Author