Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Members of Congress' Willingess to Deliberate with Constituents

Fri, October 1, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Representative democracy depends on two-way information flows between legislators and constituents. Yet previous research documents that Members of Congress (MCs) may be unresponsive to the views of typical constituents on most policy questions. Members of the mass public have non-attitudes about most issues. Consequently, MCs may emphasize getting out their message on already-formed positions, rather than learning what their constituents think. Moreover, offices are resource-constrained, so even if they believed their constituents had real attitudes, MCs seldom have the means to learn about average constituents’ opinions. This dynamic seems fatal for ambitious accounts of representation.

Recent innovations in democratic engagement—e.g., online Deliberative Town Halls (DTHs)—offer potential solutions to this problem (Neblo et al. 2018). Several MCs have already participated in these activities. Yet we don’t know how many or what kind of elected officials would participate if they were offered the opportunity. MCs may differ in willingness to participate based on party, ideology, seniority, district competitiveness, legislative effectiveness, and gender. Moreover, even among MCs who are willing, their reasons for participating remain unknown.

We address these questions with a field experiment in which we invite MCs to participate in a DTH with samples of their regular constituents. The experimental manipulation focuses on the expected benefits of participation, emphasizing the opportunity either to communicate their views to their constituents, or to learn their constituents’ considered opinions. We analyze who wants to deliberate, and the effects of message framing on participation.

Authors