Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

The Politics of Wicked Problems: Complex Systems and Democratic Governance

Sat, October 2, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

In recent years, the term “wicked problems” has come to encapsulate a perspective on complexity that rejects predictive or linear approaches to planning. From the “super wicked problems” of climate change (Levin et al. 2012) to the problems of administrative innovation involving interdisciplinary and creative methods (Gruendel 2020, Bason 2010), the concept is mobilized to describe complicated and intractable issues not easily addressed through conventional rational policy solutions but that instead demand the involvement of diverse groups of stakeholders. Wicked problems, therefore, are routinely invoked not just as a critique of rationalist approaches to planning and policymaking but also to justify innovative democratic alternatives. This paper suggests that the concept of wicked problems provides a particularly helpful framework for making sense of complex dynamic systems and that it gestures towards a positive program with new types of experts and a whole new set of professions. Perhaps the clearest elaboration of such a positive program is advanced by an unlikely group of practitioners: designers who today are involved in a variety of fields from public administration to environmental infrastructure buildout.
This paper progresses in three steps. First it elaborates on the current debates that have taken up wicked problems as a core feature. It is invoked to recast the role of technical expertise as the best and only source for legitimate solutions to complex problems and to justify bringing the experience of regular people into planning and policy making. Second, it traces the genealogy of the concept along with the movement of its inventor, the German mathematician and systems scientist, Horst Rittel. Together with his coauthor the urban planner, Melvin Webber, Rittel deployed the term in a seminal paper, “Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning” (1973), to describe the difficulties to plan for pluralistic democracy. While this famous publication appears to offer a critical response to technocracy at the tail end of high modernism in planning, its origins go back to much earlier debates in postwar West-German science planning as well as to a reflection on the 1960s crisis of the urban planning profession in the United States. And finally, the paper traces the positive program that emerged from these two very different contexts, suggesting that we can find in them a redefinition of the role of technical experts and public participation in political decision making for complexity.
A history of the concept, therefore, allows for insights not only into the current usage of wicked problems as a particular conceptual approach to complex systems but it also offers a new perspective on contemporary technical democracy and the current shortcomings of participatory approaches. Thus, wicked problems and some of the contemporary sites in which it is taken up–particularly in the various new design fields that have become installed in political institutions–raise important questions about how our politics today must answer to both the need for technical expertise and pluralistic demands in addressing complex problems.

Author