Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Woman authors continue to make rare appearances on political theory syllabi, especially prior to the nineteenth century. Sure enough, the pool of female political thinkers is much smaller than that of their male counterparts. For much of history, women simply did not have the same access to education, nor the same opportunities to write. And yet, a few possible candidates have not received the consideration they deserve. Focusing on Christine de Pizan (1364-c.1430), I argue that the inclusion of women authors in our teaching canon is desirable not merely for the sake of representation, but—more importantly—for connecting particularistic identities and viewpoints to a shared human experience. Weaving back and forth between Christine’s biography and her allegorical writings, I aim to show how Christine’s classical education allowed her to rise above the particularities of her situation and to connect her own experiences and sorrows to a rich tradition of inquiry into the human condition.
Christine de Pizan would have been a remarkable woman in any century. Born in Venice to a court physician and astrologer, she moved to Paris with her family at the age of four when her father entered the service of King Charles V. In 1379, she married Etienne du Castel. The marriage appears to have been “a singular happy one.” Etienne died young, however, and, widowed at the age of 25, Christine was left to support three children, her mother, and a niece. Faced with serious financial difficulties, she turned to writing to make a living. Her love ballades caught the attention of wealthy patrons and Christine became the first professional woman of letters in Europe.
Thanks to her pioneering role as a woman in the literary world, there is a tendency among scholars to examine her work through a feminist lens and to describe her as a “forerunner of all subsequent movements in behalf of women’s rights.” Early in her career, Christine was involved in a literary debate over the merit of Jean de Meun’s Romance of the Rose. Willard observes that “The element of feminism was injected into the debate by Christine, who was prepared to admit some of the literary qualities of Jean de Meun’s poem, but … deplored his attitude toward women… It was this feminist aspect of the debate that caught popular attention, since to find a woman rising to the defense of her sex against the sort of attack that was traditional through the Middle Ages was quite unheard of.” Christine’s ensuing moral defense of women remained a prominent theme in her writings throughout her life. Yet, what makes her works most remarkable is not simply the vindication of her gender, but her engagement with canonical texts and the way in which her perspective as a woman was transformed through her study of classical sources.
In this essay, I argue that the traditional portrayal of Christine as a “proto-feminists” is overly simplistic and distracts from a more profound observation she makes about her own identity: Through her reflections on classical texts—represented in allegorical encounters with Dames Reason and Philosophy—Christine comes to know herself not merely as a woman, but as a human being and she learns to perceive the multiple layers of her identity. I focus on two works—The Book of the City of Ladies and The Vision of Christine—to trace her journey from despair over the slanderous representations of her gender (a commonplace in medieval literature) to new certainty of her own identity. Her study of philosophy enables Christine to transcend the narrow perspective afforded by her gender and to acquire a broader view of her person as a rational human being capable of excellence in human virtue. In turn, she is no longer confined by descriptions of her gender but able to transcend and challenge them. The self-knowledge obtained through the study of philosophy allowed Christine to rise above her hardships, encouraging other women to do the same. Christine never parted with her perspective as a woman and she understood that many women would not be willing to give up family to follow a path of learning, but she sought to embolden them “to stand on their own feet, to make some sort of contribution to society, to dominate the conditions of their lives that make or break them.” In short, rather than merely defending distinctly feminine qualities, Christine wanted women to come into their own as rational beings.
Finally, I make a case for the inclusion of Christine in political theory syllabi, especially in the era of identity politics. I suggest that her writings illustrate how classical learning allows one to transcend the narrow viewpoint of one’s particularistic identities without losing them. Christine’s writings show how particularistic identities—be they based on gender, ethnicity, race, sexual orientation or other—can sometimes furnish but very narrow perspectives on ourselves and the world. Indeed, they can be confining and oppressive. However, literature, including political theory texts, can mediate between particular situations and common human experience.