Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Patriotic Identity and Affect as a Cause of Accuracy-Based Processing

Thu, September 30, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

The information processing literature demonstrates that a wide variety of factors lead Americans to be biased, directional, information processors. Direction-based processors seek and process information to confirm their pre-existing beliefs. The most notorious such factor is partisanship. Strong partisans frequently process information in such a way as to confirm their impressions and attitudes. Perhaps the most well-known example is that one’s evaluations of the economy shift depending on whether or not a President belongs to a partisan’s political party. In contrast, scholars pay little attention to the factors that lead to accuracy-based processing. However, studies of aggregate-level political behavior suggest that at least some of the electorate must process information in such a fashion. For example, scholars find that real economic changes impact economic evaluations, which in turn affect vote choice (e.g. Erikson, MacKuen, and Stimson 2002).

We propose that under certain conditions, patriotic affect (positive national affect) and patriotic identity (national in-group identity) lead Americans to process information using accuracy-based, rather than directional, motives. In a general sense, in-group affect and identity lead group members to want their group to benefit and flourish. Scholars who do study accuracy-based processing find a variety of circumstances lead to its increase – particularly group belonging (Baumeister & Leary, 1995), and civic duty (Groenendyk 2013). Of course, the identities and affects that result from national belonging are among the most pervasive and powerful (e.g. Theiss-Morse 2009), with civic duty operating as a related set of norms and values that reinforce the health of the nation (e.g. Blais and Achen 2019).

How do accuracy-driven effects differ from directional ones? Accuracy motivation leads people to exert increased mental effort in forming an opinion, relying on more complex decision rules (Kunda 1990). Accuracy driven individuals seek out more expert information, more diverse viewpoints, and are less reliant on political predispositions when making up their minds (Pietryka 2016). Motivated by accuracy goals, people conduct more complete searches for relevant information and perform less biased evaluations of the information they encounter (Baumeister & Newman 1994; Fiske & Taylor 1991; Tetlock 1985).

We propose that when the nation is under direct threat, stronger patriotic affect and national identity lead Americans to use information to more accurately evaluate the threat. We test this hypothesis using data collected from surveys, and an original experiment conducted through Prolific in the week before the 2020 Presidential election. With these data we test the hypothesis using economic evaluations, and also evaluations of the COVID-19 pandemic. The results support the hypothesis. Analyzing 2016 ANES data(n = 2,500) with a multivariate ordered probit model, we find that economic evaluations had a stronger impact on vote choice among Americans higher in patriotic affect and national identity. While the predicted probability of voting for President in Trump in 2016 was the same among those with the most positive economic evaluations, among those with the weakest such evaluations, those highest in the affect and identity were the most likely to support him. Using the results of an analysis that held the other covariates in the model at their mean, and among those with the most negative economic evaluations, respondents high in patriotism had a predicted vote probability of 0.65, and those low, a predicted probability of 0.45 (the difference is statistically significant at the p<0.05 level with a two tailed test). Analysis of a fixed effects model using 2008-09 ANES panel data also produces hypothesis-consistent findings.

Turning to the experimental results of the 1,623 participants, we primed patriotic affect and national identity using two different patriotism primes: A video of the American flag and national anthem, and an article stimulating American national in-group pride. Compared to a neutral prime, both primes increased in-group affect and identity. We also randomly assigned participants to an article with positive COVID-19 information, negative information, and a neutral, non-COVID article. We find that in the conditions of primed patriotism, the articles had stronger effects on: President Trump’s approval, Congressional approval, approval of one’s mayor, trust in government, economic evaluations, Trump’s COVID approval evaluation, COVID policy scales, and Presidential vote choice.

Authors