Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Media Coverage of Fact-Checking and Elite Spread of Misinformation

Sun, October 3, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Fact-checking by the media can correct misinformed beliefs among the public (see Walter, Cohen, Holbert, & Morag, 2019), but can the threat of fact-checks covered in the media pre-emptively influence the spread of misinformation by elites? Building on prior work (Nyhan & Reifler, 2015), the study takes advantage of a new partnership between a prominent fact checker (FactCheck.org) and a major media organization (Hearst Television Inc.) initiated just prior to a highly salient and misinformation-saturated event - the Senate impeachment trial of President Donald Trump. The current field experiment explores the influence of fact-checking on misinformation in policymaker social media posts related to the impeachment.
In the current study, in early 2020, during the Senate trial of President Trump, all U.S. state legislators were randomly assigned to a) a treatment condition, receiving a series of emails informing them about a new partnership between local media outlets and FactCheck.org, a fact-checking site; b) a placebo group informing them that they are part of a research study, or c) a control group. To account for potential spillover effects, all legislators in five randomly selected states were assigned to d) a statewide control condition to create a baseline in which no legislators in the state received either the treatment or placebo. We collected all tweets posted by legislators in the sample related to the impeachment, and coded whether the tweet included false statements as reported by major fact checking sites. The average effects of the treatment emails are estimated with regression analysis with standard errors clustered by state.

Authors