Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Israel’s Securitization Dilemma: BDS and the Battle for Israel's Legitimacy

Tue, September 28, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Since even before its inception in 1948, Israel has faced efforts to delegitimize its right to exist. More recently, however, calls for its international isolation as an apartheid pariah state have been growing. These efforts, led by the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement, are increasingly finding support among liberal audiences in the West who have previously been supportive of Israel. This paper, based on my upcoming book, interrogates Israel’s response to these delegitimization efforts and asks why Israel constructed delegitimization as a security threat and how this construction impacted its responses to the delegitimization efforts against it.

This paper begins by examining how the Zionist movement, and later the state of Israel, have dealt with various longstanding efforts to delegitimize Israel’s standing in the international community, including by the Arab League Boycott, the United Nations, and the Boycott, Divest and Sanctions (BDS) movement.

Through historical and archival research, as well as discourse analysis and interviews with Israeli policy makers, the paper argues that Israel has constructed perceived and real challenges to its legitimacy as ontological threats that undermine its national security, and has securitized its Jewish identity in response to these threats. As a result, the state has adopted extraordinary measures, often marked by illiberalism. Rather than enhance Israel’s international legitimacy, these measures have undermined it further, especially among liberal audiences in the West, whose support is critical for Israel’s continued international legitimacy. Therefore, Israel is locked in a securitization dilemma— where actions taken to enhance its security through increased legitimacy result in further delegitimization. Developing a model of how the securitization dilemma operates, and highlighting the ways this securitization dilemma is at the heart of Israeli policymaking today — particularly in the context of the recent BDS movement — this paper brings into focus key problems that Israel faces as it attempts to combat delegitimization movements against its self-constructed identity as a Jewish state. This paper directly connects to themes of pluralism (and challenges thereof) as well as Israel's democratic backsliding and the challenges majorities and minorities face in ethnic states.

Author