Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Finding the Soul(Cycle): Embodied Self-Mastery in the Neoliberal Fitness Regime

Fri, October 1, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

How have the demands of what and who is considered a “self-mastered” citizen changed over time, and what are the implications of this change? The creation of the self-mastered citizen remains the goal of liberal society, yet the ways in which this is achieved, and what it looks like, has changed. Under the neoliberal regime, I argue, the project of self-mastery, and consequently the making of the self, is embodied and focused largely on perfection of the physical form. This perfection creates an exclusionary conception of politics, where those who do not have the time, money, or accepted body to participate in fitness and further perfection of the body are excluded from political life.

In order to make this claim, I begin with a genealogical analysis of self-mastery. This genealogy begins with readings of the ancients Plato and Aristotle, proceeds through an analysis of self-mastery in liberal societies vis a vis John Locke and John Stuart Mill, and concludes with a reading of the “disciplined subject” through Michel Foucault and Wendy Brown. Throughout this genealogy, I maintain the argument that until coming under the neoliberal world order, the project of self-mastery remained an outwardly facing project with the goal of a self-mastered citizenry being motivated by a desire to create a better society overall. Departing from this vision is the neoliberal disciplined subject who is, I argue, committed to a mastery of the body instead of a mastery of the mind.

Recognizing the body as a site of both politics and self-mastery, I argue that the neoliberal disciplined subject becomes distanced from the political sphere through the erasure of the distinction between the cultivation and mastery of the mind and cultivation and mastery of the body. While Aristotle argued that the self-mastered citizen could not work on both the mind and the body simultaneously, today, I argue, the mind and the body have become marketed as an entity that can be mastered together through a mastery of the physical body. In order to make this claim, I analyze the marketing strategies taken up by four popular fitness chains in the United States: Orange Theory, SoulCycle, Pure Barre and CorePower Yoga. Each of these fitness chains promises consumers that by attending a fitness class they will not only perfect their bodies, but also create and/or find the best version of themselves as whole.

When self-mastery becomes “for sale” through participation in fitness classes, the understanding of oneself as part of a larger, politically engaged community disappears. This not only leads to a politically unengaged citizenry, but also to a political and social community whose membership is predicated on participation and adherence to standards of bodily perfection. This excludes people with undesirable, “fat” bodies, along with people who do not have the money or time to devote themselves to physical perfection. Therefore, I argue, it is necessary to consider the body, and the project of perfecting it, as a site of politics and political exclusion.

Through both a historical and contemporary examination of the concept of self-mastery, I put forward the idea that the body itself is a site of neoliberal self-making, and serves as a dividing line between those who have the ability to flourish and those who remain relegated to the sidelines of social and political life. While much analysis has been done about the ways in which the neoliberal world order works to industrialize health, along with every other aspect of life, an emphasis on the ways in which bodies physically appear in space has been largely ignored when conceptualizing neoliberalism.

It is absolutely necessary to not only recognize the body as a site of politics, but to understand how the neoliberal disciplinary regime excludes differently embodied people from participation in the projects of both self-making and politics as a whole. I conclude with the argument that understanding the role that physicality plays in the world today is imperative towards moving past a neoliberal regime that privileges and elevates thin, white bodies. While neoliberalism has many aspects that deserve analysis and criticism, bringing the body back into these analyses, as I argue in this paper, is imperative.

Author