Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Beyond the Warring Gods: The Political Weber Reconsidered (Pre-Recorded)

Sat, October 2, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Max Weber’s contribution to political philosophy is widely recognized. However, his political ethics has divided interpreters from the very beginning. One debate in particular is of central importance in understanding the controversies around Weber’s heritage in political theory: the confrontation between Leo Strauss and Raymond Aron in the aftermath of the Second World War. The dialogue between the two political thinkers, which unfolds in the context of an interpretive divide between those who focus on Weber’s tragic pathos and conflicting view of politics and those who portray the German sociologist as the representative of a sobering realism, allows to shed a new light on the problem of the “polytheism of values” and the possibility of a rational adjudication of practical evaluations. While Strauss considers that Weber’s theory of knowledge deprives us of criteria to distinguish between right and wrong and thus leads to nihilism, Aron maintains that it provides essential resources to elaborate a theory of political action. In analyzing the practical implications of Weber’s epistemology, I argue that the nihilistic interpretations fail to take into account the productive character of Weber’s theorization of the antinomies of political life. In contrast, the Aronian reading demonstrates the importance of these antinomies in developing a theory of political responsibility. This paper also demonstrates that the renewed interpretations of Weber’s political thought among European scholars are indebted to Aron’s prudential reading.

Author