Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Comparing “Ecumene” and “Tianxia”: A Case Study

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

1. Abstract
The present proposal aims to expose the actual interest of the author on developing a Post-doctoral project in the area of Comparative Political Theory. Particularly, the Comparative Study of ancient Western and Chinese socio-political order patterns, with the primary objectives of employing and evaluating a new analytical paradigm in comparing two socio-political symbolism Ecumene and Tianxia [天下]. For this work, the author intends to apply a critical political hermeneutical methodology to analyze the representative interpretation of Ecumene and Tianxia. Unlike existing methods used in comparative studies on civilizations/cultures/religions/politics, the new analytical interpretative-empirical paradigm is based on the interpretation of the Theory of Order of Eric Voegelin (1901-1985), which blends the interpretative principles and empirical materials and possess the characteristics of openness to experience and tolerance to multiplicity in the reality of human existence. The importance of this research is that it can offer a justifiable paradigmatic contribution to the Comparative Political Theory. Additionally, the research can also provide a critical analysis of the fever for Tianxia/Tianxia-ism in contemporary China; subsequently, it can supplement the ongoing studies on Multiple Modernities initiated by Shmuel Eisenstadt (1923-2010).
Specifically, the research will be divided into six sections. The first section will analyze and summarize the premises and interpretative principles of the Voegelinian interpretative-empirical paradigm. The second and third will explore and analyze the representative literature on Ecumene and Tianxia. The fourth will compare the crucial meanings of the two symbolism. The penultimate will analyze the Tianxia/Tianxia-sim in a contemporary socio-political context. The last section will put the current research into the contemporary discussion of comparative modernity/Comparative Studies and supplement the multiple-modernities approach with the empirical case on Ecumene and Tianxia.
2. Intentions and Methodology
This research aims to provide a tentative inspection for the above theoretical problems concerning exploring legitimate analytical principles for the Comparative Political Theory, searching for an evenhanded mutual understanding among heterogeneous communities, and analyzing the changing of the self-understanding/interpretation in China, a community that has undergone revolutionary socio-political changes since the beginning of the last century. To this end, the research will conduct a case study based on the comparison between two equivalent dominant socio-political symbols: Western “Ecumene” and Chinese “Tianxia” based on Eric Voegelin’s Theory of Order, which can be regarded as an interpretative-empirical paradigm on order patterns in the history of human existence. The interpretative-empirical paradigm possesses two interrelated levels of hermeneutic foundations and empirical materials to penetrate the socio-political human existence in history. Voegelin’s consideration of order provides the theoretical bases and principles to understanding the reality of human existence at the hermeneutic level. Notably, it provides the epistemology/hermeneutics of self-understanding as an applicable method to analyze the process of human existence in reality. The theory of order intends to cover various kinds of order modes (experience and its symbols) of human existence in different conditions at the empirical level.

Author