Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Waiting for Capitalism: Abstinence and Expectation in the Nineteenth Century

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Max Weber famously concludes “The Protestant Ethic” with a mournful reflection on the “iron cage,” an ossified spirit of capitalism that has made the “care for external goods” an unbearable yoke of consumerism and vanity. In this paper, I propose to read Weber’s conclusion as a sign of the uneasy, if widespread, reception of an increasingly hegemonic capitalist paradigm: waiting = profit. If early iterations of the “labor theory of value” were full of the promise of action and increasing productivity, nineteenth-century economics took a turn for the tame. Theorists from J. S. Mill and Alfred Marshall to Weber himself, had each identified the merits of waiting for capitalist development.

How did passive accumulation and a degree of ‘world denial’ come to take precedence over the kind of initiative and risk-taking that Adam Smith had prized just a few decades earlier (later revived in the early 20th century)? The paper proposes that the formula "time = profit" reflects the changing nature of capital itself with industrialization and gives a concrete price to the subjective aspects of capitalist time: expectation and abstinence. It thus epitomizes the Enlightenment ideal of progress, but also its attendant anxieties. By tracing the causes for the rise of waiting, the paper elaborates the costs of this new principle and sheds light on the backlash against it, from Marx and Nietzsche to John M. Keynes.

Author