Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In the early years of the Obama Administration, Hillary Clinton’s State Department crafted an ambitious agenda to promote democratic norm adoption in and through cyberspace. At the time, the global Internet had come to appear as the ultimate avatar of 21st century economic and cultural globalization, under-girding growing cross-national interdependencies that were often thought to correspond with liberalizing influence. The past decade has substantially challenged any simple understanding of the Internet’s influence on regime type, however, as well as demonstrating the numerous new security dilemmas and threats to national security that the global dissemination of inherently dual use digital technologies can entail. This paper draws on over a decade of data to examine the dynamics of norm development and contestation in cyberspace, particularly tracing the relationships of democracy promotion, authoritarian learning, and national Internet policies. Examining patterns and trends in Internet content censorship, surveillance, and national Internet laws during this period demonstrates increased differentiation between more authoritarian and democratic approaches to Internet governance, as well as an overall decline in the influence of the “Internet freedom” agenda as previously conceived.
In considering reasons for the relative decline in influence of the US-led norm promotion effort, the paper argues that conceptual incoherence played an important and underappreciated role in undermining US leadership, often contributing to growing distrust, security dilemmas, and charges of duplicity or hypocrisy by critics and adversaries. Rather than stemming from any sort of intentional duplicity, however, the paper suggests that underlying sources of conceptual incoherence in emerging areas of digital policy have developed naturally as a result of bureaucratic path dependence and mimesis that have produced separate, stove-piped, niche expert policy communities, often lacking fully integrated appreciation of the connections across different digital policy areas, and at times leading to conflicting agendas. As today’s global digital technologies increase interdependencies between countries, the dual use nature of these technologies brings both potential positive-sum benefits and more zero-sum areas of competition and risk, leading at times to competing policy visions emerging from different areas of government. Particularly stark contrasts and sometimes contradictory approaches have coalesced around areas of democracy and human rights, economic growth and development, and national security. Examples are drawn from national and international debates over policy concerning Internet content, cybersecurity, digital surveillance, and transnational data flows.
The US is now embarking on a new decade of digital policymaking during a period where the need for coherence and leadership in democratic Internet governance has never been clearer. The paper concludes with a warning that, in order to avoid the mistakes of the previous decade, there must be a critical reexamination of the sources of incoherence in previous digital policy. Procedural and structural innovations to address these problems and ensure a more unified whole-of-government approach will be an important first step in renewing US leadership in this vital area.