Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Political Leadership and Pandemic Response in the UK

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

The Coronavirus 19 pandemic has deeply disrupted the normal social and economic life of political systems around the world. In many democracies it has led to restrictions on personal movement such as curfews, bans on meetings between families, the closure of schools and all but essential retail activity and the increasing limitations on domestic and international travel. Such incursions on personal freedom are unprecedented in peace time and indeed the crisis posed by the pandemic has in many respects taken on the features of a war. One important variable in evaluating how successfully individual countries have coped with the crisis is political leadership – the power to mobilise the resources of the state and society to address the crisis and to adopt a series of measures which on many different dimensions would normally be deeply unpalatable to their populations. Yet leadership is not a simple phenomenon. Obviously it involves the personal characteristics and leadership style of the individual leader or leaders who exercise political authority in the system . But it also necessarily involves the structures through which they operate – the policy-making institutions and the advice structures as well in a democracy as the support and legitimation mechanisms of the legislatures and their parties. In addition the implementation of policy will be likely to depend upon a range of other institutions and actors from local authorities and officials to specialist professionals. Effective leadership also requires constant attention to followers to maintain morale , whether they be party elites or activists, key pressure groups, or the general public. In this process of retaining support the role of communication and the media is clearly crucial.

The paper looks at the United Kingdom’s leadership in the handling of the Coronavirus pandemic. It assesses the features of the leadership style of the prime minister and key cabinet ministers and evaluates the criticisms of their decision-making especially the criticism that they were too slow in taking key decisions about lockdown restrictions and that their shifts of strategy undermined public confidence. It moves on to assess the strengths and

weaknesses of the structures of the political and administrative system, including the cabinet’s committees and its mechanisms for dealing with emergencies ; and it evaluates the extent to which the mechanisms for transmitting medical , modelling and scientific evidence presented problems. Finally it assesses the political and cultural factors which promote or constrain political support and legitimacy - the divisions within the Conservative Party (and especially the backbench Recovery Group chaired by Mark Harper), the stance of the opposition parties , the role of devolved and decentralised political institutions (including those of the National Health Service itself), and the perspectives of private sector business and trade union leaders . It evaluates the government’s strategy for communicating its policies in the context of a constitutional system of multiple actors and institutions and a highly adversarial political culture.

Author