Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

What Is Naturalism in Political Science?

Thu, September 30, 6:00 to 6:30am PDT (6:00 to 6:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

In a series of recent publications, Mark Bevir and Jason Blakely have argued that debates over research methods in political science should re-focus on the philosophical question of continuity between the social and natural sciences, or the truth of what they call “naturalism.” Bevir and Blakely argue against naturalism by arguing that explanations in the social sciences, unlike the natural sciences, are fundamentally interpretive. I claim that their argument does not succeed for two reasons. First, the claim that the status of interpretative explanation cleaves the social from the natural sciences requires a correct understanding of explanation in the natural science. I argue that Bevir and Blakely's argument relies on an incorrect and overly narrow conception of explanation in the physical and life sciences. Second, even if the social sciences are interpretive in important ways, this does not identify a necessary, conceptual difference from the natural sciences. I argue that is because question of naturalism's truth can only be settled by the contingent result of engagement between the natural and social sciences rather than identifying an necessary difference between concepts like “meaning” or “action” and concepts in the natural sciences.

Author