Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Re-examining Security Cooperation Through Multinational Military Exercises

Sat, October 2, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Research on international security cooperation has traditionally focused on military alliances. Yet, states interact in multiple other forms, such as multinational military exercises (MMEs): cooperative, non-combative simulations undertaken by the militaries of multiple states intended to improve future military cooperation. Though MMEs and alliances both serve as signals, they diverge on several fronts. First, military exercises occur more frequently than the signing of alliances. A newly compiled dataset shows at least 3,000 MMEs occurred between 1980 and 2010. Second, MMEs act as more of a sunk-cost; exercises are not only financially expensive but also entail the basing of troops abroad, lowering a sending country’s defensive strength. Third, MMEs exhibit broad diversity in terms of participant coalitions: allies, non-allies and even rivals partner in military training. This paper describes patterns of MMEs over time to highlight key differences between forms of cooperation and discusses resultant theoretical implications.

The higher frequency of military exercises compared to alliance formation makes them a more accurate proxy for the alignment of states’ security interests. For example, just looking at the presence of an alliance would show that the US, Turkey and Greece have been aligned since the 1950s. However, this measure would distort the true alignment of their security preferences. MMEs, on the other hand, show that for decades Greece refused to cooperate militarily with its NATO allies because of a minor legal disagreement over the status of some small islands.

Multinational exercises allow scholars to expand literature on signaling. Much more work has been done on tying-hands signaling and crisis bargaining than their sunk cost and peacetime counterparts. MMEs entail non-trivial costs to perform, and take place both in times of war and peace. The range of available MME data allows researchers to see how countries respond to non-conflict events; for example how countries like Malaysia and Indonesia reacted to the Asian financial crisis of the 1990s or how the global economic downturn of the late 2000s shaped global MME patterns.

Finally, as a measurement of security cooperation, MMEs allow researchers to not only re-examine existing theories with a different measurement but also compliment existing literatures. For example, military exercises provide new measurements for theories relating military compatibility and coalition formation and theories of security cooperation among rivals. MMEs also add nuance to the existing ordinal alliance institutionalization measurement.

Author