Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In the wake of the coronavirus pandemic, unemployment in the United States reached historic levels, with widespread economic insecurity persisting months after the pandemic’s onset. Health impacts continue to be widespread, with more than 1 in every 1000 people in the U.S. dead from COVID-19. Yet, a rising pandemic toll does not necessarily correlate with greater public attention or action. In fact, past research suggests that as a crisis event affects more people, individuals are worse at comprehending the true magnitude of impact (Kahneman 2011) and are less likely to act in response (Västfjäll et al. 2014).
People’s difficulty comprehending and responding to the true magnitude of crisis events is partly due to how the brain processes information (Slovic 2010). To manage limited bandwidth, the brain uses dual systems: the automatic system (System I) processes stimuli quickly, in part by using affect and association to make quick connections and assessments; the deliberative system (System II) uses logic and conscious thought. System II often yields more accurate assessments; however, this comes at the cost of consuming more cognitive bandwidth.
Human response to stress exemplifies this tradeoff in cognitive bandwidth. Stress captures attention and activates System II processes for what otherwise would be routine, automatic decisions (Spears 2011; Radel and Clément-Guillotin 2012), leaving less bandwidth available for other mental tasks. As stress captures cognitive bandwidth, consequences include weaker self-discipline, decisions based on shorter time horizons, and the consideration of fewer choices in decision-making. Impacts of stress on cognition and performance are particularly evident for people experiencing financial hardship. For example, priming people to consider impacts of a financial shock lowers performance on cognitive tests, and economic stress consumes mental bandwidth that would otherwise be used to optimize other decisions (Shah, Mullainathan, and Shafir 2012, 2019).
In light of this work on crisis, stress, and cognition, I test two main questions: Does active consideration of the pandemic’s impact affect cognitive performance? Are there downstream consequences for one’s intent to take political action?
In an October 2020 survey of 1666 U.S. residents, I randomly assign half of respondents to describe (in about 30 words, or the length of a social media post) negative impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. I find that priming consideration of pandemic’s negative impacts decreases cognitive performance and increases self-reported cognitive load. On average, the treatment group completed 0.15 fewer correct Raven’s Matrices (p=0.06, two-tailed test), with effects strongly driven by high social media users. The treatment group also showed significant increases (99% confidence) in self-reported cognitive load, change in cognitive load during the pandemic, and worry about the pandemic’s impact on one’s mental health.
In this study, higher objective and subjective cognitive load measures also predict increased interest in future political action. The average conditional mediated effect (ACME) of the treatment on political interest via poorer cognitive performance is significant at 95%, and sensitivity analysis provides additional support for cognitive load mediating the relationship between negative pandemic reflections and political action. I leverage a follow-up study (75% recontact rate) after the 2020 U.S. presidential election to test whether respondents translated their interest in political action into real engagement. I find that my treatment condition corresponds with a significantly larger gap between stated interest in political action and implementation.
My study is particularly relevant in a social media era when individuals frequently distill their reflections and reactions to current event into fewer than 280 characters. This experiment sheds light on how short acts of commentary like tweeting change how cognitive bandwidth is allocated – thereby itself potentially changing how we perceive (and act upon) the status quo. This project helps understand how conscious engagement with political events or stressful situations on social media can affect a) attention available for other tasks, b) political interest, and c) political action.