Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Human rights are usually met with high praise or skepticism. But what picture do we get when we take a hard look at the process of negotiations of the Universal Declaration of Human rights - the first human rights document at the United Nations (UN) and the bedrock for the current framework of human rights? This paper conducts an ethnography of documents of the documents and summary records of the three first sessions of the Human Rights Commission, between 1947 and 1948, to understand how values and affects were embodied by state, NGO and UN representatives to shape the potentialities and limits of human rights. Complicating narratives that explain the contours of the document - declaration that is not binding, no enforcement mechanism, etc, by an unwillingness of states to let law constrain power, I place hope, accidents, deadlocks, power asymmetries, and deferrals at the heart of a tension that permeated the initial construction of human rights, and that persists today. I argue that the actors who were in charge to define, enforce, and protect human rights battled with how to reconcile notions of morality and political responsibility. By crafting human rights at the dawn of a new international institution, the “makers” of human rights, were also drawing lines around the individual, the citizen, the state, and the international, and the world, while experiencing and performing rights and limits themselves. As a result of this process, the UN mostly gained moral responsibility over the “abstract” individual while the state reinforced its prerogatives in shaping and cultivating the “social human being”. Historicizing the “human” aspects of the deliberation process replaces a teleological view of the development of human rights with a narrative that refuses both to take limits in human rights as given or inevitable and sits uneasily with the notion that they can be easily done away with in the future.