Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Antebellum Virginian Pro-Slavery Thought as Reaction

Sun, October 3, 12:00 to 1:30pm PDT (12:00 to 1:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Over the course of the 1830s-1850s a series of Virginia polemicists, including Thomas R. Dew, Nathaniel Beverley Tucker, and Benjamin Watkins Leigh, penned defenses of slavery that provided a framework of “positive good” arguments for slavery. Attempting to make sense of these defenses and the associated positive good theory within the American tradition, “Consensus” historians of the mid-Twentieth century portrayed them as backward-looking remnants of feudal thought. Revisionists have subsequently rejected that characterization, arguing that pro-slavery thinkers understood themselves as forward-looking defenders of an Herronvolk democratic order against the destabilizing forces of interracial equality and an atomized free labor market. At the same time, scholars have increasingly identified and recovered the importance of the enslaved’s undermining of slavery through acts of marronage and resistance. This paper seeks to bring these two insights to bear on the arguments of the Virginian defenders of slavery, highlighting the latter’s perception of the recognition of the enslaved’s individuality as a potential fatal threat to slavery. Shifting focus away from questions of whether pro-slavery polemicists were forward- or backward-looking, this paper argues instead for understanding them as engaged in the articulation of a racialized conception of liberalism in which white individual empowerment was predicated upon the refusal of Black enactments of liberation. In such a reading, Dew, Tucker, and others sought not to preserve a conservative or racialized democratic system but rather to craft a reactionary rejection of Black emancipation.

Author