Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The State and Transitional Justice: A Conceptual Foundation

Thu, September 30, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Public opinion research in conflict affected countries reveals that the state is a significant reference point in people’s attitudes towards transitional justice. People frame their perceptions in terms of what the state should do, what it cannot do, what it has promised, where it has succeeded or failed, and more. Yet, to date, the various roles that the state can play in people’s understandings of and perceptions toward transitional justice processes remain under-theorized in the literature. We know that people look to the state as a provider – of peace, justice, development, security, etc. – but the notion of the state-as-patron is limited. Beyond making and fulfilling promises, how does the state influence conflict-affected communities’ attitudes toward peace, justice and reconciliation? Drawing on an original dataset from our ongoing multi-sited study of peace and reconciliation in Colombia, we use mixed methods to analyze how people’s everyday experiences and perceptions of the state mediate their attitudes toward transitional justice. Local community members frame their opinions about transitional justice through the issues and problems they face in their daily lives, like safety, income and health, along with more intangible aspects of life under conflict like memory, coexistence, vengeance and forgiveness. What we see, however, is the striking persistence of the state as a reference point in perceptions across all of these categories and more. The locally sourced indicators underscore that the kind of state (engaged in justice, development, or security processes) and the level of state (local, regional, or national) that people experience in their everyday lives mediates their perceptions of transitional justice processes implemented on the ground.

Authors