Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Power Transition, Regional Order, and the Rise of the Manchu Qing

Fri, October 1, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

It is widely recognized that the premodern tributary system in East Asia, characterized by its Confucian rhetoric, hierarchical relationship, and tributary trade and rituals, reached the apex under the last imperial dynasty of China—the Qing (1644-1911). Yet, the Qing Dynasty was ruled by a non-Han ethnic minority: the Manchus. Recent scholarship on the ‘New Qing History’ also highlights the Manchu identity embedded in the reign of the Qing. How did the Manchu Qing manage to champion the Confucian tributary system in the regional order of historical East Asia? This paper develops a theoretical model that combines the realist and constructivist insights, and analyzes the international relations of the Ming-Qing transition in the early 17th century. It shows that the Manchus were initially discontented with the ‘humiliating’ treatment it received under the tributary system of the Ming Empire. However, as it rose to challenge the regional hegemony of the Ming, the Manchu Qing increasingly adopted the languages, the rituals, and the practices of the tributary system. Being both an emulation strategy to balance against the Ming and a socialization strategy to entice the Ming’s tributary states, the Manchus not only accepted and adopted the Confucian way, but promoted and championed the tributary system to an unparalleled level. The paper then discusses the implications of the Manchu experiences for the rise of China.

Author