Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Imagining Altruism: A Discourse Analysis of the Giving Pledge

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Private philanthropy has become an increasingly important topic for normative political theorists, given the massive influence that wealthy donors and foundations exert over public policy. Advocates of “effective altruism” focus on maximizing the returns of elite philanthropy through quantifiable, means-tested methods; critics worry that elite philanthropy can hollow out public services and introduce a plutocratic bias into public policy by giving wealthy donors unequal voice.

This paper offers an interpretive analysis of the so-called “Giving Pledge.” The “Giving Pledge” is a movement, started by Warren Buffett and Bill Gates, encouraging the super-rich to donate at least half their wealth. Donors must write a letter formalizing their decision to sign the pledge. In practice, these “pledge letters” offer remarkable insights on the mindset of today’s mega-donors—an unprecedented data set that I am now analyzing for the purpose of determining how these billionaires self-conceptualize their own place in democratic societies.

By paying close attention to the language employed in the pledge letters, I identify various “folk” conceptions of desert, privilege, opportunity, responsibility, civic obligation, and distributive justice, among other themes. These reflections are nestled within more personalized reflections on the vocation of the philanthropist in a market economy, on the proper way of doing philanthropy, and on the relationship between philanthropy and the good life.

These pledge letters display, then, a surprisingly complex and multilayered “normative grammar” which also underscores the intense personal and ethical importance of philanthropy in the lives of the super-rich; an ethical dimension that must command our respect. But while many letters acknowledge the wider normative dilemmas (such as rising inequality) that have accompanied the growth of elite philanthropy, they are generally less willing to think critically about the philanthropist’s own elevated position in contemporary democratic societies.

This paper thus makes findings relevant to both the literature on philanthropy and to wider debates in political science on the relationship between pluralism, private wealth, and civic life.

Author