Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
With few exceptions, existing theories of internal violent conflict are typically generated and tested in cases outside the United States (US). Yet, recent political developments in the US suggest an analytical pivot is in order. During the last 10 years, the US experienced heightened polarization, widespread and sustained political protests, ongoing acts of terrorism and mass shootings, and increased visibility of armed militias. At the same time, there is growing evidence that affective polarization based on out-group threat from partisan adversaries is radically reshaping US partisanship and political behavior. These developments have led many Americans to shift their perceptions of threat away from an external “other” and toward their fellow citizens, with many fearing civil war. Indeed, perception of threat is a primary concern for civil war scholars. However, studies on threat perception in the US context typically seek to explain American attitudes toward an external threat. American perceptions of threat toward other Americans are far less understood. What factors contribute to threat perception among compatriots in the US?
To answer this question, we draw on 6 months of original ethnographic field research with left and right populist groups including the Tea Party, Trump supporters, Occupy Wall Street, and Sanders supporters in northern Michigan. Based on this qualitative data, we find that vicarious experiences – that is, experiencing or knowing someone who has experienced or felt a given threat or risk – influences perceptions of threat toward other US citizens, despite sharing a national identity. Since populist supporters believe mainstream sources of information reflect elite bias, they instead rely on personal and vicarious experiences from within the populist in-group to shape their political knowledge. Sharing stories of threat to Christian conservative identities emanating from out-groups including Democrats, Muslims and immigrants, constitutes a key mechanism to reinforce in-group identities and spur political mobilization to protect from threats. As a result, group members' perception of risk from out-groups increases, and they become more likely to demonize and engage in conflict with fellow citizens. We test the generalizability of these findings via an original survey that examines the construction of threat perception among both left- and right-leaning populist supporters in the US.
Our findings advance existing knowledge of contentious politics by synthesizing theories of threat perception from the civil wars literature with scholarship on risk perception that emphasizes the power of vicarious experience. By locating our analysis within the US context, we add an important but understudied case to the empirical evidence on civil war processes while contributing to pressing discussions about current unrest in the country.