Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Role of National Intelligentsias in Nation-Building: A Nested Analysis

Thu, September 30, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Existing explanations for the formation and salience of national identities point to the role of deep structural variables like mass native-language literacy that generated “great divides” in Europe and Eurasia. A growing body of more recent econometric evidence further suggests that these divides, in some places like Poland and Ukraine, have persisted across generations. However, as I demonstrate, deep structural explanations can only partially explain variation in national beliefs within regions.

In this paper, I introduce a new, more proximate driver of salient national beliefs – national intelligentsias. In other regions, research has documented how “communal elites” with nationalist credentials can mobilize protest around identity-based appeals. In Eurasia, the Soviet experience empowered a specific class of writers, artists, university professors, and other cultural intelligentsia with these credentials. I contend that the presence of national intelligentsia was instrumental in pushing communal grievances that would become the foundation for independent national sentiment in the Soviet republics in the later decades of the USSR.

With a nested design, I first use historical data on Soviet literacy rates to determine where the structuralist conventional wisdom over or under-predicts nationalist mobilization in 1988-91. The Soviet republic of Armenia emerges as a deviant and “least likely” case that over-performs expectations based on pre-communist nationalist schooling by itself. To account for this, I argue that, in Armenia, national intelligentsias played a proximate causal role in challenging Soviet concepts of multi-nationalism and “friendship of the peoples.”

Through fine-grained descriptive inference, and drawing from a rich collection of in-person interviews and archival primary sources, I illustrate that the causal sequence implied by my theory did play out in the case by showing: (1) that Armenian intelligentsia qualified as “communal elites” that could mobilize mass constituencies, (2) that Armenian intelligentsia radicalized and accelerated the national movement by pushing communal grievances associated with a territorial dispute and then tying them to independence, and (3) that Armenia’s uniquely positioned intelligentsia originated with a brand of orthodox nationalism that emerged decades earlier, during Khrushchev’s “thaw” period of relaxed authoritarian constraints. I also follow Azerbaijan as a shadow case to show that, at each stage in this causal sequence, the absence of a comparable national intelligentsia prevented the emergence of a similarly independence-minded mass movement.

This case comparison and the large-n relationships it is nested in should compel scholars of national identity to refocus attention away from deep structures and historical legacies towards more proximate elites with nationalist credentials and mass constituencies.

Author