Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Designed for Men? The Logistics of Disaster Relief

Wed, September 29, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

During times of acute need – hurricanes, major wildfires, severe floods, and pandemics – militaries are often called in to assist. Military logistics, in particular, can be put to work in figuring out complicated supply systems, providing transport, offering medical care, and carrying out evacuations. However, militaries differ in their abilities to provide such services. What makes a military better suited for disaster relief? This paper argues that in order to answer this question, one must consider the role of gender.

Militaries are masculine institutions whose resources and systems are predominantly designed to serve the needs of male service members. This extends to the provision of sanitary kits, to the construction of bases and equipment. Put simply, the logistics of ensuring that soldiers get to where they need to be, on time, and with the necessary equipment is designed with the male body in mind. This paper examines whether militaries that invest in logistical changes to provide the health and human services to all personnel, regardless of gender, are likely to be more adept at providing aid during a crisis. I argue that the degree to which a military organization invests in recruiting and retaining a gender inclusive force will influence its ability to provide organizational and logistical assistance to the broader civilian population. Militaries that invest in institutional commitments to inclusion – for example through the reduction of occupational restrictions based on sex or sexual orientation, the expansion of family programs, and sexual assault and harassment monitoring – are more likely to have the needed flexibility when it comes to altering its approach to treatment, allocation of resources, and other standard operating procedures. In other words, I expect that militaries that can provide for a more inclusive fighting force, will also be better able to assist the broader civilian population in times of need.

To test my theory, I utilize an original dataset of Institutional Commitments to Inclusion (ICI) across all NATO member and partner countries from 1991 to 2016 to compare how militaries with varying levels of inclusion have engaged in disaster relief. The ICI index measures the extent of institutional commitment to gender inclusion across a series of possible indicators, including occupational restrictions, formal rank restrictions, percentages of the total active force, family programs, harassment policies and monitoring procedures, and LGBTQ+ exclusions. In this paper I expand the index to include indicators such as the gender-based retrofitting of bases and equipment, and the provision of feminine care services to deployed personnel. To compare disaster relief protocols, I rely on interviews with military personnel, defense experts, and government officials, as well as the analysis of government documents, military journals, news articles, field manuals, and other primary sources. Preliminary findings indicate that more institutionally inclusive militaries, such as the Australian Defense Force, are especially adept at the provision of disaster relief.

Author