Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Effects of COVID on Group Inequality and Ethnic Attitudes: Evidence from Lagos

Sat, October 2, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

COVID has generated a wave of economic and social dislocations, but less is known about how the pandemic will affect group inequality and ethnic conflict. This paper addresses two questions. First, to what extent are the economic effects of the pandemic distributed evenly within economic vulnerable populations, or do identity-based differences (here, indigeneity and ethnicity) affect the economic impact of the pandemic? Secondly, do COVID-related economic hardships have political consequences? Here, we are particularly interested in whether increased economic hardship might generate higher levels of ethnic attachment or a rise in xenophobic attitudes. These are especially important questions for the fast-growing cities of the developing world, which are diverse spaces.

In order to examine these questions, we draw on a multi-wave phone survey conducted with 868 market vendors in Lagos, Nigeria. Informal sector workers in low-income countries are among the world’s most vulnerable to COVID-related lockdowns and regulations, because they rely on daily income to survive and typically lack access to state protections, including aid that might mitigate the impact of sudden economic shocks. In our setting, up to 80 percent of the labor force is employed in the informal sector, and Lagos is highly diverse in terms of religion, ethnicity, and place of origin. Though the majority of Lagosians are ethnically Yoruba, our vendor population is fairly evenly split between Yoruba and non-Yoruba vendors. A portion of our sample identify as indigenes, which marks them off from Yoruba who migrated to Lagos from other states. The first wave of our survey was conducted in the wake of a five-week total lockdown in Lagos, during which residents were ordered to stay at home.

The results from our first round survey suggest that COVID-related economic losses have been more substantial among ethnic minorities. Our preliminary results also suggest that COVID-related economic losses have intensified anti-minority sentiment among members of the ethnic majority and, especially, indigenes. In the paper to be presented at APSA, we will track whether these effects were sustained over the course of 2020 or if they were important but non-durable effects of the early stages of the pandemic. In the proposed paper, we leverage a rich set of questions that allow us to differentiate between different kinds of ethnic attitudes. First, we consider a group of measures we see as capturing “social polarization,” or an individual’s preference for his own ethnic group and animosity toward others. Second, we look at xenophobic attitudes, such as whether respondents believe that Lagos is a city open to all and whether minorities and new migrants should be barred or given lower priority in the allocation of government aid. Our intuition is that those who express stronger in-group preference are not necessarily xenophobic, but these individuals may become more receptive to xenophobic rhetoric or may adopt more exclusionary views should economic conditions worsen. Further rounds of survey data, which will be available prior to APSA, will give us some leverage on these temporal dynamics.

Authors