Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Painful Political Healing In America: Lessons from South Africa TRC

Sat, October 2, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

The American two-party political system is one of the key engines for the proper functioning and success of the American project in democracy. From the standpoint of system analysis, both political parties must operate in healthy ways, while also maintaining a mutually fulfilling relationship. And yet the current political crisis and polarization in America reveal an increasingly dysfunctional American political system. Uncivil political discourses, widespread public misinformation and disinformation as well as threats of and actual anti-government violent acts that culminated with the storming of the United States Capitol in January 2021 suggest the prevalence of hyper partisan relations that increasingly renders the American political system a toxic and ill-functioning one, at dangerous levels.

Calls for healing abound. But what does it mean exactly? How to get there? In fact, what is the justification for healing, if one considers politics the very realm of conflict and competition of power relations? This paper makes the argument that from the standpoint of system analysis, a two-party political system carries with it structural tendencies that ultimately respond for either its optimal functioning or its failure. But individual and collective behaviors of the units - or actors - operating within the system also shape such structural tendencies. It is the interplay between agency and structure that allows for long-lasting and productive dynamics. At both levels, the principle of inclusion and complementarity is what assures the viability of the system on the long run. Shared norms is not enough. Shared ideological principles based on perceived shared values is required in support of agreed norms of conduct and expectations. To that aim, the historic account of the South African post-Apartheid Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) will serve as a case study and an analytical model in search for lessons that could be applied to American politics, if the goal is indeed true, long-term healing. In particular, the TRC represents an empirical instance of the philosophical principle of Ubuntu and its centrality for collective efforts towards reconciliation.

For the understanding of how the TRC model may be applied to American politics, two analytical steps are required. First, the functioning of a bipolar political system results from the interplay between instances of (a) dichotomous polarizations and (b) intersection configurations. The former reflect opposing, competing forces, often interpreted as political realism. The latter reward integration, which can only truly counter-balance extreme polarizations if embracing the Ubuntu philosophical principle of community, rather than mere transactional instances of cooperation. Second, one must understand the principle and application of Ubuntu and how it is at the very heart of the TRC and its application of justice. While the concept is a multidimensional one in scope and meaning (and even with contested and fuzzy interpretations), at its core lies the foundational appreciation for inclusion and diversity as its driving force, while also demanding personal and collective embrace of accountability.

After exploring the historic case of TRC and its guiding philosophical principle of Ubuntu as well as their potential lessons for an American political system in crisis, the paper concludes with some remarks on how feasible it really is for one to expect that American society may embrace Ubuntu. To identify what is required for a healthy functioning of a two-party political system in crisis having the TRC and the philosophical principle of Ubuntu as analytical frameworks is one thing. Another altogether is to assess whether the American society has the willingness to recognize the magnitude of its current political crisis and its causes and whether it has the fortitude to take the painful but necessary steps toward the truth and reconciliation. South Africa has showed the world that it is possible. Could it be done in America?

Author