Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How Sure Is Sure? Certainty and Ambiguity in Science-Based Policymaking

Tue, September 28, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Instrumental communication of scientific uncertainty in science-based policymaking has been documented, but not systematically reviewed. Notably, a few scholars have examined cases of intentional obfuscation of scientific consensus and fomentation of doubt in scientific evidence (Freudenburg et. al., 2008; Oreskes 2011). In this paper, we use congressional hearing transcripts from 2002-2017 to evaluate messaging tendencies with respect to science-based policy. We determine how expressions of probability and levels of certainty (e.g., likely, unlikely, possibly, etc.) are used by different actors, and how the use of these expressions changes over time and across administrations. We identify the conditions under which members of Congress and hearing witnesses, including bureaucrats, experts, and interest group representatives, emphasize or minimize scientific uncertainty. Specifically, we examine the relationship between the levels of certainty expressed and: identity of the speaker, majority party status and corollary agenda setting power, the policy topic, and the committee’s reputation vis a vis bipartisan cooperation or partisan acrimony. We test the following hypotheses: 1) members of Congress seeking to preserve the policy status quo emphasize scientific uncertainty more so than members of Congress seeking to change the status quo; 2) members of Congress seeking to preserve the policy status quo emphasize scientific uncertainty more so than hearing witnesses; and 3) the magnitude of these relationships is greater in hearings held by committees traditionally characterized as more partisan than in committees devoted to policy areas traditionally considered less partisan. Our findings largely confirm our expectations and reveal both subjectivity and conditionality in the communication of scientific uncertainty during the policymaking process. This paper makes an important stride in documenting and understanding politicization of scientific uncertainty.

Authors