Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Institutional Foundations of Recusal Behavior in State Supreme Courts

Sat, October 2, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

In his 2017 book entitled Ethics and Accountability in the Supreme Court: An Analysis of Recusal Practices, Robert Hume argued that recusal behavior in the United States Supreme Court is governed by statutory, institutional, and policy-related considerations and constraints. My study relies on and extends Hume’s work to state supreme courts. Because nearly every state requires state court judges to make a subjective decision to recuse themselves whenever their “impartiality might reasonably be questioned,” the analysis helps political scientists and legal scholars to understand the extent to which state court systems and in particular state supreme court justices are committed to the principle of impartial justice. Whereas debate surrounding the recusal behavior U.S. Supreme Court Justices Antonin Scalia and Elena Kagan are well publicized in recent years, this study explores an important subnational context, state supreme courts, where recusal behavior of justices remains a black box. Importantly, I have assembled an original recusal dataset from 1995 to 2019 involving 38 state supreme courts, including large states such as California and small states such as Rhode Island. These data allow us to make a detailed examination of various institutional motivations and characteristics of state laws that undergird recusal behavior in state supreme courts. The data also allow us to identify the most important institutional, policy, and statutory reasons why state supreme court justices recuse or fail to recuse themselves.

My proposal will fit in well with any panel on state supreme courts and institutional legitimacy.

Author