Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Legacies of Radical, Liberal, and Aborted Liberal Approaches in Southern Africa

Fri, October 1, 3:00 to 3:30pm PDT (3:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Five Southern African countries with a shared history of entrenched settler colonialism experienced, in the second-half of the twentieth century, a historic episode known as liberation struggle. Yet these countries are marked today by contrasting regime types and forms of social polarization: i.e., inclusive semi-democracy in Angola and Mozambique, polarized “social” democracy in South Africa and Namibia, and exclusionary semi-authoritarianism in Zimbabwe. Most analysts explain these divergent outcomes in terms of state structures and modes of racial-class domination associated with settler-colonial rule, emphasizing deep political continuities between the colonial and the post-liberation periods. Others emphasize ideological and organizational differences among the liberation movements that assumed power following the demise of settler-colonial rule. I offer an alternative path-dependent explanation that traces the contrasting outcomes of the liberation-struggle episode to different approaches to change—i.e. “radical” (Angola and Mozambique), “liberal” (South Africa and Namibia), and “aborted liberal” (Zimbabwe)—that were adopted by liberation elites after achieving national liberation. I argue, first, that the alternative policy options help to explain political dynamics that varied across the five countries following liberation as well as the contrasting long-term “legacies” of the liberation episode that characterize the region today. I further argue that radical, liberal, and aborted liberal policy approaches were largely contingent outcomes influenced by the specific set of opportunities and constraints that faced radical elites at the moment of national liberation—and not reactions to deterministic structural conditions or ideological differences among liberation leaders. The study employs a critical-juncture framework of analysis, and uses comparative-historical methods to test hypotheses and develop a general explanation through broad cross-case comparison (Bayesian and counterfactual) and highly contextualized within-case analysis (i.e. process tracing).

Author