Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Accomodationist or Socialist Institutions? Trade Unions and Machine Production

Sun, October 3, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

The emergence of trade unions as the primary vehicle for worker organization in the latter half of the nineteenth-century generated widespread theoretical reflection on their relationship to the capitalist economy. Trade unions first came to prominence and gained legal recognition in the most advanced capitalist economy of the period, England. Understanding the English trade union movement’s aims, successes, and failures was crucial for developing one’s own view about the status of trade unions. The two German thinkers who contributed most to trade union theory in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries – Lujo Brentano and Eduard Bernstein – both spent significant time in England studying the trade union movement. Brentano was a prominent member of the German professorial class and the so-called historical school of political economy. He viewed the English trade union movement’s non-revolutionary development after Chartism as a model for the continent and defended the idea of a harmonious relationship between capitalists and workers. Bernstein was a revisionary Marxist theorist, journalist, and the intellectual forefather of social democracy. While Bernstein saw much to be emulated in the English trade unionism, he believed the lack of an English socialist party had crippled trade unions’ capacity to bring about transformational economic change.

A comparison of Brentano and Bernstein’s views on trade unions can help us better understand the points of disagreement between accomodationist and socialist conceptions of worker organization. This paper argues that different views on the nature of capitalist activity lead to different conceptions of trade union politics. If one understands the capitalist as a neutral intermediary, then industrial harmony is possible between workers and capitalists with little state intervention; if one sees capitalist activity as systematically undermining workers’ capacity to organize, unions need to be connected to a broader political struggle that generates feelings of solidarity among workers and passes legislation to protect against capitalist activity’s worst consequences. Brentano’s belief in the possibility of industrial harmony rests on the idea that capitalists are neutral intermediaries between workers and consumers: worker wages came from consumers, not capitalist’s profits. The capitalist’s task is to organize production in a manner responsive to consumer demand and, when this function is fulfilled, the capitalist receives a profit. State intervention in the labor contract is only legitimate when capitalists violated their duty to mediate between workers and consumers in order to enrich themselves at the expense of both. Brentano believes that the proper arrangement of a corporatist chamber of labor would prevent aberrations from this ideal of intermediation.

Bernstein argues that bourgeois economists like Brentano fail to appreciate how the conditions of machine production present problems for union’s ability to effectively press for wage increases. Machine production creates a stark hierarchy between unskilled and skilled workers, as machine-related work either requires mere supervisory activity or genuine command over the mechanical process. This hierarchy manifests itself at the level of industries: some industries employ predominantly unskilled workers, while others maintain a larger share of skilled workers. The first problem Bernstein identifies is confined to industries with far more unskilled workers. In these industries, the capitalist’s interest in increasing his rate of return creates an unskilled industrial reserve army that makes it difficult for trade unions to increase wages. This is because the capitalist can always substitute the organized workers with members of the industrial reserve army. A second problem is that the capitalist introduces premium wages within industries with a majority of skilled workers in order to increase productivity and his rate of return. This creates a disjuncture between elite and non-elite skilled workers’ interests: the former see a minimum wage as coming at the expense of their own premium wages. Bernstein’s solutions to these problems involve factory legislation – and, as he argues in 1919, the socialization of industries with predominantly unskilled workers – and the unifying activity of union leaders and the social democratic party. Social democratic unionists aim to generate a shared class interest between elite and non-elite workers in reducing capitalist profits. These provide the conditions for effective union organization and ensure the emergence of institutions that counter the full development of capitalist accumulation’s tendencies. Bernstein rejects Brentano’s neutral intermediary view of capitalist activity: the capitalist’s interest in ‘valorizing’ his capital systematically disadvantages the worker even if the capitalist does not violate the rules of fair exchange.

Author