Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This paper analyzes Adam Smith’s critique of monopoly in The Wealth of Nations.Different from previous interpretations, I find Smith identified monopoly as a much more systematic problem posed by an entire class of stockholders in a commercial society.Despite the magnitude and depth of the problem, however, I also find that Smith did not propose any large-scale solution to restrain the class of stockholders; instead, he developed a persuasive account that asks the government not to support monopoly rather than endorsing the use of coercive power to contain monopoly’s social origin. My paper explains why Smith refrained from advocating a direct ban on the collusion of the class of stockholders. While previous interpreters attribute Smith’s refrainment to his skepticism of politics, my explanation connects Smith’s economic theory to his moral and rhetorical theories and ascribes his refrainment to his normative understanding of the relationship between economic exchanges and persuasion. Smith did not call for correcting economic pathologies through governmental intervention because he believed that economic exchange should be a realm of persuasion free from the use of force. For Smith,it is only when exchanges are conducted solely by persuasion that equity and utility are likely to converge, and that individuals’ pursuit of self-interest can lead to care for others’interests, practices of sympathy and persuasion, and thus advancement of sociability in the commercial society.