Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Building the Biometric State: Citizen Response to a State-Building Intervention

Tue, September 28, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Investments in state capacity often represent mixed signals for citizens: both the increased ability of the state to extract and surveil, as well as its increased ability to deliver welfare-enhancing goods and services. Empirical evidence on how citizens respond to these multifaceted investments, however, is scarce: when do they fortify linkages between state and citizen, rather than triggering disillusionment and defiance, and why? I study the mass issuance of biometric identity cards by the Ugandan government in 2014, when nearly the entire adult population was registered and issued IDs by the army in a period of six months. Such schemes have recently spread rapidly across the Global South and have become important for the administration of a wide range of governance outcomes. To isolate how citizens’ beliefs and expectations were shaped by exposure to this intensive intervention, I leverage the fortuitous timing of a social survey which was enumerated during the rollout and draw on administrative data relating to the rollout itself. I find strong evidence that the scheme led to increases in citizens’ perceptions of the legitimacy of the central state and their quasi-voluntary compliance with its demands, and only limited evidence of defiance and pushback. These positive effects are offset by negative effects on attitudes and allegiances towards local political authorities otherwise responsible for brokering access to state resources. The results suggest how even seemingly intrusive investments in the state’s capacity can strengthen state-citizen linkages and centralize the locus of political control.

Author