Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
It is striking that a thinker whose image has been tarnished by his embrace of German fascism looms so large over the emerging sub-discipline of comparative political theory (CPT). Indeed, one would imagine a field dedicated to intercultural understanding and pluralism would have little time or space for a man convinced of the singular destiny of the German Volk. Nevertheless, Martin Heidegger is a notable and direct inspiration to many of the most influential scholars in or adjacent to the field, including Fred Dallmayr (“Beyond Monologue”, 2004, p. 250), Charles Taylor (Retrieving Realism, 2015, p. 128; “Heidegger, Language, Ecology”, 1995) and Dipesh Chakrabarty (Provincializing Europe, 2000, p. 18, 254). Of particular importance to their work is Heidegger’s attention to the local or historical character of human life and the diversity of ways of being-in-the-world, his critique of the “Europeanization” of the planet under technological modernity, and the prominent place he gives in his work to the theme of dialogue.
Given the ever-accumulating revelations of Heidegger’s commitments to National Socialism, it is worth both highlighting and reevaluating his place within CPT. To do so my paper will both outline Heidegger’s under-appreciated influence on the field and ask: what would a Heidegerrian, rather than Heidegger-inspired project of comparative political theory look like? What possibilities does Heidegger genuinely open to the field, and likewise, what dangers might he pose? To do so, I will focus on the works of Heidegger that most directly touch upon the theme of intercultural dialogue, including "Hölderlin’s Poem 'Remembrance'”, and “A Dialogue on Language”. Ultimately advocating caution, I first argue that while we can indeed learn from Heidegger’s meditations on the limits and possibilities of intercultural dialogue and understanding, it is crucial to recognize that Heidegger’s pluralism is decisively inegalitarian. For Heidegger, only elect peoples gifted with a language receptive to Being, such as the Germans, ancient Greeks, Chinese and Japanese, can participate in fruitful dialogues. Secondly, while Heidegger provides the tools to engage in a comparison between ontologically diverse peoples (peoples with diverging ways of understanding and being-in-the-world), he is less helpful in assisting in the work of making political comparisons. Indeed, Heidegger infamously reduces all forms of modern politics to mere expressions of technological nihilism. Thirdly, readers should be warned that to the extent Heidegger engages in intercultural dialogues, it is not with a view towards securing mutual understanding and respect within the confines of what Taylor calls the modern moral order. Rather, Heidegger means to prepare the nations still capable of communing with Being to live up to and retrieve their national destinies precisely by moving beyond the confines of modern thought, politics and normativity.