Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

'Gramscianism of the Right': On the Use and Abuse of Metapolitics (Pre-Recorded)

Sun, October 3, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

This essay offers a critical engagement with an influential New Right argument: a) that Western nation-states are experiencing a crisis of immigration that threatens their cultural integrity or survival, and b) that this ‘demographic invasion’ is fueled by the egalitarian commitments of liberalism. Accordingly, the essay engages core figures of the European New Right to pursue two distinct lines of analysis. At one level, it interrogates the asserted connection between the egalitarian political imaginary and the demographic transformations of a global age. In doing so, the essay critically examines the ‘metapolitical’ strategy of the New Right. Though the term is a mouthful, it can be expressed in rough strokes: in order to pursue meaningful institutional change, it is necessary to transform the social imaginary at a more fundamental level, within the sentiments, images, and normative vocabularies that structure civil society. Here, the New Right stakes its politics on what it terms a ‘Gramscianism of the Right’. This project does not simply diagnose the ideological levers for broad-scale demographic transformation; instead, it attempts to reinvest and restage these normative languages in order to organize a public around ethnonationalist aims.

The overriding argument of the essay is that this ‘Gramscianism of the Right’ (whether pursued by the European New Right or its North American counterparts) does not simply appropriate the normative vocabulary of liberalism toward antiliberal objectives. Rather, the costs run deeper. By pursuing this metapolitical strategy, the New Right literature ultimately hollows out the substance of the normative terms it takes over, which has deleterious consequences for a democratic public. In destabilizing the normative anchors for civic life, this metapolitical strategy erodes the basis of a democratic common. In doing so, it contributes to contemporary dynamics of polarization in which citizens increasingly cannot decide on common histories, common ideals, common values, or common truths.

Author